New York
21 August 2017
Reporter: Stephanie Palmer

ISDA: Transition period essential for post-Brexit derivatives trading


The International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) has urged UK and EU regulators to implement transitional provisions for derivatives trading after Brexit.

In a whitepaper, ISDA highlighted the need to secure legal certainty for derivatives trading between UK and EU counterparties after Brexit is finalised in March 2019.

The paper urged the UK and EU to “agree on post-Brexit transitional provisions for contracts under English law to reduce complexity and costs for all market participants”.

It noted that the European Commission has identified a need for safeguards to support the financial and monetary policies of EU institutions, and added that, following Brexit, a “substantial volume” of cleared derivatives may no longer be be subject to the EU supervisory architecture.

The paper said: “The vast majority of EU clearing currently takes place in London, but there are suggestions that EU regulators might introduce a location policy for euro-denominated swaps to be cleared in the EU.”

In June, ISDA sent European Commission vice president Valdis Dombrovskis a letter, setting out some of the economic and financial implications of any such location policy for the clearing of euro-denominated derivatives

These issues included: price volatility and execution costs; increased systemic risks; complexity and operational risk as legacy transactions have to be migrated; costs of splitting netting sets; and reduced access to CCPs for end users.

In today’s announcement, ISDA added that the UK and EU authorities should “instead agree appropriate arrangements for oversight and cooperation with respect to UK CCPs”.

With regards to price volatility and execution costs, the paper noted that any location policy applying to certain contracts would artificially exacerbate differences in pricing between CCPs, raising concerns around liquidity in the case of a location policy coming into effect.

It said: “As a location policy can only be enforced on transactions where at least one counterparty is located in the EU, it is to be expected that the clearing pool in the eurozone will be less liquid compared to the current globally integrated pool. Less liquidity will lead to less competition and less choice, and potentially wider bid/ask spreads.”

The paper also pointed to the G-20 derivatives reform commitments, including the commitment to avoid fragmentation, protectionism and regulatory arbitrage, saying: “An EU CCP location policy would run contrary to the deference principle, and would fragment markets.”

It went on: “A CCP location policy would be damaging to EU economic interests, and should not be pursued.”

Complexity comes from the fact that most cross-border transactions in complex financial instruments in the EU are governed by English law. It is unclear, currently, whether this will change after the UK leaves the EU

“If transitional provisions are not put in place, it may result in an increase in complexity, more uncertainty and higher costs for market participants,” ISDA said, concluding that, in order to remove any legal uncertainty around cross-border contracts, transitional arrangements should be implemented “until a proper system of mutual recognition is introduced”.

More news
The latest news from Asset Servicing Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Ten-year T2S saga comes to an end
19 September 2017 | Brussels | Reporter: Stephanie Palmer
The Target2-Securities pan-European harmonised settlement platform is finally fully operational, as the Spanish and Baltic markets completed their migration yesterday
SS&C on point with launch of Precision LM 3.0
19 September 2017 | Windsor | Reporter: Theo Andrew
With improvements spanning across the loan production, servicing and technology functions, the Precision LM 3.0 upgrade also includes expandable web services, helping to improve operational efficiency
Linedata and DTCC keep partnership going
19 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The new updated programme, Extensible Markup Language allows Linedata clients to match transactions across extended asset classes, and enables trade processing on one platform
PwC promotes into leadership roles
19 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Theo Andrew
Elizabeth Stone will be responsible for working with asset and wealth management clients across audit, tax, advisory, deals and legal services across the UK
Euroclear-DTCC and Lombard Risk link collateral management programmes
18 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Lombard Risk has partnered its Colline solution with DTCC and Euroclear's GlobalCollateral margin transit utility (MTU) programme
Sanne backed as fund administrator by Central Bank of Ireland
18 September 2017 | Dublin | Reporter: Theo Andrew
Under Section 10 of the Investment Intermediaries Act, Sanne will now be able to provide services to Irish authorised collective investment schemes and alternative investment managers
New COO joins Calastone
18 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Theo Andrew
Stephen Mohan joins from DST Systems, formerly IFDS, where he was most recently executive director of transformation and innovation
More news