04 September 2017
Reporter: Jenna Lomax

BCBS: Fintech could spell trouble

The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) has argued banks need to prepared for the possible implications of fintech saying that, despite the plethora of opportunities technological change could bring, they also present strategic, cyber and liquidity-related risks to the banking sector.

The consultative document, Implementations of Fintech Developments for Banks and Bank Supervisors, said banks and banking supervisors have a responsibility to maintain the same level of risk management control standards, despite of their increasing reliance on fintech.

The paper focused on forward-looking scenarios and industry predictions about emerging fintech. Drawing from the collection of evidence, the Basel Committee warned that the industry faces risks and “needs to ensure safety when considering compliance standards that do not inhibit beneficial innovation”.

However, the document also alludes to the new opportunities fintech can also bring, not only for consumers, banks, the banking system and bank supervisors, but also for consumer protection, allowing for greater transparency and tighter controls over spending and budgeting.

That said, there is plenty of uncertainty in terms of managing and monitoring risks brought about by recent and rapid fintech developments. The document suggests that fintech will likely lead to more competition for banks, which, given the aftermath of the 2007 financial crisis, could be a bad turning point for the industry.

According to BCBS, one risk is that “existing financial institutions stand to lose a substantial part of their market share or profit margin if new entrants are able to use innovation more efficiently and deliver less expensive services.”

Cyber risk is also likely to increase in all future estimations. The report said: “New technologies and business models can increase cyber risk if controls do not keep pace with change, the paper discusses.”

The document went on: “Although liquidity can increase efficiency, it can also affect customer loyalty and increase the volatility of deposits. This in turn could lead to higher liquidity risk for banks.”

Elsewhere, the fintech element of distributed ledger technology (DLT), which is arguably still in its infancy, could be a concern, as some solutions still display limited scalability and a lack of data privacy and industry standards.

In light of these risks, BCBS suggested that there is an increased need for cooperation across the sector.

The paper recommended: “Banks should ensure they have effective IT and other risk management processes that address the risks of the new technologies and implement the effective control environments needed to properly support key innovations.”

Banks should also “ensure they have effective IT and other risk management processes that address the risks of the new technologies and implement the effective control environments needed to properly support key innovations”.

The report also suggested that more cooperation within the industry would only increase stability and security.

“This coordination may provide more consistent and effective supervision related to areas such as consumer protection, data protection, competition and cyber-security”, it said.

The committee also stressed the importance of supervision of third-party service providers, stating some are guilty of a “degree of oversight”.

It said: “Third parties that provide critical services to large numbers of financial institutions may pose systemic risk to the financial sector and raise the concerns of bank supervisors as to the safety and soundness of their operations.”

Finally, BCBS found that, while some bank supervisors had supervision programmes in place, the majority only supervise third-party service providers “under limited circumstances”.

BCBS proposed that it is paramount for future stability in the sector for supervisors to share information on policies and practices among regulators, not just among themselves.

More news
The latest news from Asset Servicing Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
SLI goes live on Calastone’s settlement service
23 November 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Standard Life was added to the solution following its £11 billion merger with Aberdeen Asset Management, which was completed in March this year
BNP Paribas hires new Hong Kong head
23 November 2017 | Hong Kong | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Kasparian will be responsible for developing relationships with new and existing clients, as well as delivering best-in-class operations and services
Monyx selects RBC I&TS to manage SICAV umbrella
23 November 2017 | Luxembourg | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
RBC I&TS will provide custody, fund administration, transfer agency, securities lending and foreign exchange services to Monyx
Societe Generale boosts ESG reporting
22 November 2017 | Paris | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The new solution allows institutional investors and asset managers to rate their investments against ESG indicators
Tobam launches bitcoin mutual fund
22 November 2017 | Paris | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The fund will allow investors access to cryptocurrency to benefit from Tobam’s research and IT systems to track the value of investing in bitcoin
Strate adopts Nasdaq blockchain solution for voting
22 November 2017 | Stockholm | Reporter: Becky Butcher
Nasdaq is set to provide its blockchain electronic voting solution to South African Central Securities Depository (CSD) Strate
UniCredit launches instant payment solution
22 November 2017 | Milan | Reporter: Becky Butcher
UniCredit has launched its cross-border instant payments solution in Italy and Germany
More news