New York
23 January 2017
Reporter: Drew Nicol

Northern Trust warns of repo timebomb


The repo market could “shut down” under stress conditions with pension funds most at risk, according to a new Northern Trust whitepaper.

Pension funds are caught between sustained low interest rates and “the unintended consequences of a variety of market regulations,” explained authors Mark Austin and Steve Irwin.

“In times of market stress, the repo market could shut down, or a bank may not be able to provide an investor with direct cash,” the paper continued.

Therefore, funds must diversify their portfolios’ liquidity sources in order to gain the “strongest protection” against future market turbulence.

According to the whitepaper, some pension schemes are increasing their allocation to cash to as much as 7 percent of their portfolios.

In previous environments, investors could earn as much as 2 to 3 percent by holding cash, but, today, they must settle for no returns, or even suffer negative rates.

“Cash has gone from being a benign by-product of investing to arguably the essential facet of a lot of investment strategies.”

Turning to regulation, Irwin and Austin cited the US Dodd-Frank Act, the European Markets Infrastructure Regulation and the EU’s Solvency II Directive as all bringing unintended consequences through their liquidity requirements.

A separate report by the Dutch asset manager APG and the Dutch pension fund provider PGGM, two of Europe’s largest pension funds, along with the Insight Investment and MN, estimated that if European pension funds were required to centrally clear derivatives trades and post cash for variation margin, the total collateral required for a 1 percent rate shift would range from €205 billion to €255 billion. In more stressed scenarios, it could reach €420 billion.

“If interest rates in the current market environment move by a quarter of a percent—which some industry participants argue would not be uncommon—then, collectively, European pension funds would be required to post intra-day margins of approximately €55 billion, stated Northern Trust’s paper.

"So, while more central clearing has de-risked the market, it has unintentionally given investors new kinds of liquidity challenges.”

By way of possible solutions to what the paper describes as the “liquidity conundrum”, funds should identify “unusual sources of liquidity”, such as securities available for repo activities or securities lending.

Funds should also maintain a liquidity ladder to forecast needs and match them with known cash flows, while modelling the asset liquidity profile and stress testing it to understand the true benefit and cost of embedded funding costs, as well as margin requirements on derivatives positions.

More fund services news
The latest news from Asset Servicing Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
Pension fund mandate for BNP Paribas
21 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The West Sussex Pension Fund is the fifth appointment BNP Paribas has secured under the Local Government Pension Schemes (LGPS) National Framework Agreement
SIX: Speedy settlement key in collateral management
21 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Stephanie Palmer
Real-time settlement is the most important consideration when choosing a new collateral management provider, according to research from SIX Securities Services
Sanne backed as fund administrator by Central Bank of Ireland
18 September 2017 | Dublin | Reporter: Theo Andrew
Under Section 10 of the Investment Intermediaries Act, Sanne will now be able to provide services to Irish authorised collective investment schemes and alternative investment managers
RBC and IHS Market collaborate on MiFID II research payment solution
12 September 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Research payments will be administered from RBC-maintained accounts, using IHS Markit’s RPA Manager, at the discretion of each individual firm
BNY Mellon wins mandate from sustainable investment specialist Arabesque
07 Seotember 2017 | New York | Reporter: Stephanie Palmer
Asset management firm Arabesque has selected BNY Mellon and FundVantage Trust to support the distribution of its new Arabesque Systematic USA Fund
Heritage launches AIFM risk management service
25 August 2017 | Guernsey | Reporter: Katherine Brown
Heritage International Fund Managers is launching a new portfolio and risk management service for alternative funds, through its management company solution
Allfunds to open office in the Nordics
16 August 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
Fund distribution platform Allfunds plans to open a local office in the Nordic region as it pushes ahead with growth plans across Northern Europe
More fund services news