Luxembourg
02 March 2017
Reporter: Stephanie Palmer

ITAS: UCITS V not smooth sailing yet


Although UCITS V has already been implemented, there are still issues that local regulators need to iron out, according to a speaker at ITAS Luxembourg.

Speaking on a panel on the implementation of UCITS V, Isabelle Lebbe, vice president of international transfer agency at Franklin Templeton Investments, noted that, globally, “the clients we advise are now compliant with the new regime, with a few exceptions.”

Some aspects of the regulation remain unclear, she said, and these aspect are being addressed in different ways because “we don’t have sufficient guidance”.

Under UCITS V, depositories have a duty to verify their instruction with the laws, regulation and fund rules, and this “proves to be difficult”, Lebbe said. She questioned how far the depository should be expected to go in these cases—for sharia-compliant funds, for example, it is unclear whether a depository is responsible for verifying compliance with sharia rules.

Lebbe suggested that funds and depositories should “clarify this in the depository document” in order to avoid further confusion.

The panel moderator, Andrea Mornato of Invesco Asset Management, moved on to address the issue of remuneration under UCITS V, suggesting that there are challenges from local regulators, where some have adopted clear guidelines and other have not.

He also pointed to the rage of other regimes such as the second Markets in Financial Instruments Directive and the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive, which are attempting to address the same issue, but tackling it from different angles, leading to inconsistencies.

Lebbe pointed out that, for remuneration, UCITS V includes a proportionality rule, allowing institutions to adapt the guidelines to meet their own situation. While some management companies have been quite risk averse in their implementation, others have stretched the rules, trying to stick, as far as possible, to their current position.

According to Lebbe, the Luxembourg regulator asked for proposals of implementation of the new rules, but so far “we have seen no reaction at all”.

While she argued that, while there are no clear rules there will be no strict expectation of compliance, one audience member suggested that, in fact, the regulator is purposely leaving regulations open to interpretation so that when an issue arises, it can “nail” those companies with more relaxed versions in place.

The audience member went on to say that management companies are still using these kinds of freedoms “for competitive advantage”, calling this “a fundamental problem in the industry”.

More regulation news
The latest news from Asset Servicing Times
Join Our Newsletter

Sign up today and never
miss the latest news or an issue again

Subscribe now
LEIs offer major cost savings, says OFR
17 November 2017 | Washington DC | Reporter: Drew Nicol
The OFR noted that early academic studies found that cost savings associated with adoption of the LEI approached $1 billion annually
MTS and UnaVista to collaborate for SFTR
13 November 2017 | London | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
The collaboration means that firms trading on MTS’s new global collateral management segment will be able to use UnaVista’s trade repository to trade under SFTR
LSE teams up with APIR Systems to brings LEIs to Australasia
08 November 2017 | London | Reporter: Drew Nicol
Industry estimates suggest more than 250,000 entities are still without the required LEIs
MiFID II creates “much uncertainty” for EEA members
06 November 2017 | Oslo | Reporter: Jenna Lomax
For EEA members, “much uncertainty” remains regarding ESMA's assessment of the EEA legal basis for MiFID II, according to Norway’s Finanstilsynet
SimCorp: MiFID II remains a concern for buy-side firms
01 November 2017 | London | Reporter: Becky Butcher
Some 28 percent of buy-side representatives are still unsure if and how their firm will be affected by MiFID II, just 90 days before the implementation deadline, according to a SimCorp survey
SEC grants relief to US brokers on MiFID II
27 October 2017 | New York | Reporter: Theo Andrew
The division of investment management issued three no-action letters, providing 30 months relief, allowing US broker-dealers to receive payments in hard dollars
Solvassure creates first-of-its-kind integrated reg platform
25 October 2017 | London | Reporter: Theo Andrew
The compliance platform addresses demands under the General Data Protection Regulation and the Accountability Regime, to help firms meet next year's regulatory deadlines
More regulation news